Writing and Editing: Ethical Use of AI in Scholarly Communication and Dissemination
Purpose and Context
AI tools can assist researchers in planning, drafting, editing, summarizing, translating, and formatting research materials. Used thoughtfully, AI can improve clarity, accessibility, and productivity in scholarly communication. However, using AI during the writing process raises ethical considerations involving authorship, accountability, attribution, confidentiality, tone, and integrity. Ethical use of AI in writing and editing means using these tools to support—rather than replace—human scholarship, creativity, and responsibility.
Researchers must ensure that AI contributions are transparent, verifiable, and compliant with Virginia Tech’s academic and research integrity policies, including the Virginia Tech Policy on Misconduct in Research (13020), the Virginia Tech Undergraduate Honor Code, and the Graduate Honor System at Virginia Tech. This section covers responsible AI use in writing tasks such as text generation, proofreading and editing, summarizing, formulating conclusions, adjusting tone, translation, reformatting, and preparing press releases or outreach materials.
| AI Principle 1 | Application | Tips and Considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Mission Alignment | Use AI tools to enhance research communication in ways that advance Virginia Tech’s missions of discovery, learning, and service. |
|
| Innovation for Good | Use AI to responsibly explore new ways to create, summarize, and share research findings. |
|
| Human-Centered Benefit | Use AI to enhance human creativity and communication, not replace scholarly expertise or skill development. |
|
| Responsible and Ethical Use | Ensure AI use in writing and editing complies with academic integrity, sponsor requirements, and data security policies. |
|
| Fairness & Transparency | Disclose how AI contributed to writing, editing, translation, or summarization to maintain transparency and trust. |
|
| Human Judgment and Accountability | Researchers remain accountable for all written work, regardless of AI assistance. |
|
| Data Security and Privacy | Protect unpublished manuscripts, research data, and correspondence when using AI systems. |
|
- Principles in this table are drawn from Virginia Tech’s Responsible and Ethical AI Framework (v1.0, 2025). This guidance operationalizes those principles for research contexts across the stages of the research lifecycle.
Questions to Consider
- Have I clearly disclosed where and how AI contributed to my writing, summarization, or translation
- Have I verified AI-generated or AI-assisted text, ideas, summaries, and references for accuracy, originality, and appropriate attribution to underlying sources?
- Does AI use in my writing align with Virginia Tech’s Principles of Community and standards of scholarly authorship?
- Am I ensuring that AI complements my expertise instead of replacing critical writing and reasoning skills?
- Does the AI-generated text reflect how I would explain it to a colleague in my field or to the target audience?
- Does the AI-generated text sound like me and accurately reflect my work?
Real-World Tips
Before submitting a manuscript, outreach piece, or translation that involved AI assistance:
- Document how AI was used (e.g., “ChatGPT was used to suggest grammar edits for the abstract”).
- Disclose AI involvement using the format recommended by Virginia Tech Libraries’ AI Citation Guidance and ensure the disclosure also meets the specific requirements of the journal, publisher, or sponsor.
- Verify every statement, citation, and translation for accuracy and meaning.
- Retain ownership of scholarly authorship; AI can assist with structure or style, but you are responsible for the ideas and conclusions.
- Protect both confidentiality and data integrity. Do not use public AI systems for unpublished, restricted, or proprietary research materials. Ensure that datasets and findings remain secure until they are cleared for public release or publication.
- When using AI-generated text or ideas, look for indications that the material comes from an existing source. Search distinctive phrases or concepts, consult relevant literature, and consider using a similarity-checking tool such as iThenticate for written content. Review identified sources and cite the original work when appropriate.
These steps preserve authorship integrity, comply with institutional and sponsor requirements, and model responsible AI use for students and collaborators.